Eggs Should Not Go On Potato Salad, And Here’s 7 Reasons Why

Potato salad is a classic at BBQs and potlucks, with endless variations. But one ingredient—eggs—has sparked debate. Here’s why you might want to leave them out:

  1. Texture Trouble
    Eggs add a thick, rubbery texture that can throw off the creamy consistency of potato salad. The chunkiness can be distracting, making the dish less smooth and enjoyable.
  2. Flavor Disruption
    The sulfuric taste of eggs can overpower the creamy mayo or tangy mustard, messing with the balance of flavors.
  3. Not Everyone Can Eat Eggs
    Eggs are a common allergen and digestive issue for many. If you want your potato salad to be inclusive, skip the eggs.
  4. Vegan No-Go
    Eggs aren’t vegan-friendly, limiting options for plant-based eaters. Vegan mayo can be used instead, keeping everyone happy.
  5. Short Shelf Life
    Eggs can spoil quickly, making your potato salad less safe to store and reducing its shelf life. Without eggs, it lasts longer.
  6. Eggs Belong Elsewhere
    Eggs are the star of egg salad, so why crowd them into potato salad? Let them shine in dishes where they’re meant to be the main flavor.
  7. Plenty of Other Uses for Eggs
    Eggs are perfect for frittatas, cakes, or even as a breakfast main dish. Don’t waste them in potato salad when there are better ways to use them.